Not sure how to calculate your crypto gains to report to HMRC ahead of the January tax deadline? HMRC is very clear that crypto investors must use the share pooling cost basis method to calculate their crypto gains and losses. Learn how share pooling crypto works and how to calculate your crypto gains easily.
HMRC call pooling the section 104 rule, but it's better known as an average cost basis method. Pooling crypto works like this - when you have identical assets, you pool those assets and take an average cost basis for each of those pools.
So, for example, if you had 3 ETH, with a cost basis of £2,000, £800 and £1,500 - you'd add up each cost base for a total of £4,300 and then divide it by the total amount of coins/tokens held in that pool, so 3. This would give you an average cost basis of £1,433. If you dispose of your ETH by selling, swapping, spending or gifting it (excluding to your spouse) then you'd use this cost basis to calculate any capital gain or loss to report to HMRC.
You'll need to do this for each kind of crypto asset you own, so you'd have a pool, known as a section 104 pool, for ETH, BTC, DOGE and so forth.
If you haven't already noticed - average cost basis is easily manipulated.
Investors can purposefully purchase assets at a much lower cost basis to artificially reduce their average cost basis and sell them quickly to reduce their gains and therefore their tax bill, and even buy back assets quickly after to continue holding long-term investments.
To stop UK investors from doing this - the HMRC has laid out very specific cost basis rules that define how you calculate the average cost of assets - including the Same Day Rule, Bed and Breakfasting Rule and finally, the Section 104 Rule we covered above.
There are three rules you need to follow to calculate your crypto taxes
You need to work through each of these three rules, in order, as they apply to your assets to calculate your crypto gains and losses. Let's take a look at each in depth.
If you buy and sell coins on the same day, use the cost basis on this day to calculate your gains or losses. If you've sold or traded more than you bought on that day, move on to rule 2.
The same day rule is the first rule you need to consider. The same day rule states if you buy and sell coins on the same day - you'll use the cost basis from the tokens or coins you purchased that day to calculate any subsequent gain or loss, not your average cost basis from a section 104 pool.
When you've bought and sold tokens of the same kind on a given day, all the tokens are treated as being purchased in a single transaction, and then sold in a single transaction - so even if you bought some tokens in the morning, and some in the evening at a lower price, you'd use the average cost basis and average sale price for all your tokens to calculate your gain or loss.
If you sold or traded more tokens than you bought in a single day, you'll move onto to the bed and breakfasting rule.
Also known as the CGT 30 day rule, the bed and breakfasting rule states that if you bought and sold tokens of the same kind within 30 days, you'll use the cost basis of the tokens you purchased within 30 days as your cost basis to calculate your gains or losses.
The 30 day period applies on either side of the purchase and sale.
If you buy & sell tokens within a 30 day period, you'll use the FIFO (First In First Out) cost basis method to work through your cost basis from that period, not the cost basis from your section 104 pool. This can get a little confusing, so we'll use an example to explain the CGT 30 day rule. Let's say you purchased BTC for £11,000 on the 1st, then £13,000 on the 17th and sold on the 20th, you'd use the cost basis from your purchase on the 1st, as it was the first asset you purchased within the 30 day period. If you then sold again within the 30 day frame, you'd use the cost basis from your second purchase on the 17th and so forth.
If you sell more tokens than you bought within the last 30 days, you'll move onto the section 104 rule.
The Section 104 rule, also known as pooling, says investors should use the average cost basis method to calculate an average cost for a given pool of assets. To do this, add up the total amount paid for a pool of assets and divide it by the total amount of coins/tokens in the pool. Then use this cost basis to calculate subsequent gains or losses.
Let's look at some examples to better understand how each rule works.
Ryan carried out the following transactions for Bitcoin:
1 Jan 2019: Purchased 4 BTC for £6,200
30 Aug 2019: Purchased 2 BTC for £8,800
15 Dec 2019: Sold 4.5 BTC for £27,000
15 Dec 2019: Purchased 0.5 BTC for £2,500
In this example, the disposal is first matched with the purchase made on the same day, then against the share pool.
The main reason why you have to use the 30 day rule is to prevent a practice known as bed and breakfasting where a person sells shares when they are trading at a low price to generate a tax loss and later buys the assets back to maintain his position in that asset. This is also known as a wash-sale as it is not a genuine sale. The 30 day rule makes this much more difficult as the person will not be able to buy the assets back within 30 days if he wants to use the losses.
Douglas purchased 1,000 XRP on 5 July 2018 for £10,000. The price of XRP has fallen in value, so he would like to establish a capital loss. So, he sells the shares on 2 December 2018 for £2,000 and purchases them back on 10 December 2018 for £1,900.
Douglas’s transactions are caught by the 30 day rule. The disposal on 2 December 2018 will be matched with the purchase on 10 December 2018, and for 2018–19 he will therefore have a chargeable gain of £100 (2,000 – 1,900).
Of course, for crypto investors trading large volumes - these rules pose challenges. You could have hundreds - if not thousands - of transactions. This is why Koinly has developed a sophisticated crypto tax software tool that can reliably calculate the cost basis for each of your crypto transactions and generate your final capital gains.
Koinly supports the share pooling cost basis method for UK investors. You can find this in settings.
This means Koinly can do all the calculations for you. All you need to do is head into your tax reports page and download the tax reports you need. Koinly can generate UK specific tax forms like the HMRC Capital Gains Summary.
Hopefully you now have a better idea of how capital gains are calculated in the UK according to HMRC's share pooling rules. If you want to learn more, you can check out Koinly's UK crypto tax guide which goes over the tax rules for different types of crypto transactions as well as ways of reducing your taxes.